I give these a 5 because of all the protein that is in them and because they taste good, and are organic. I have eaten several different recipes of these now. I prefer this one because it is less oily than the previous one. I wish it held together a bit better, though. It tends to break, at least, in half, unlike the previous version. When I am out working and have less than clean hands, I would like it to hold together. I also am not really detecting any chocolate taste in these much anymore, just peanut butter.